Top 10 Scottish Shortbread Brands Reviewed

Shortbread is a staple of Scottish baking — simple ingredients, exacting technique, and an emphasis on butter-forward flavour. We sampled ten well-known brands available across Scotland and beyond, scoring each for crumb, butter richness, texture, packaging and overall value. Below are our findings plus buying notes so you can choose the biscuit that best suits your cup of tea.

How we tested

All samples were at room temperature and tasted within five days of opening. We evaluated each biscuit across five categories on a 1–10 scale and calculated an overall rating out of 10. Categories included:

• Butter intensity (how rich and buttery it tastes)
• Texture & crumb (crispness vs. melt-in-mouth)
• Balance (salt-sugar balance)
• Packaging (freshness and presentation)
• Value (price-to-quality)

The top 10

1. 1. Muirhead’s Highland Shortbread

   Rating: 9.2/10

   Pros: Exceptionally buttery, fine crumb, attractive tin packaging. Cons: Slightly pricier than supermarket brands. Verdict: Best overall for gifting and special occasions.

2. 2. Glenfinnan’s Original

   Rating: 8.7/10

   Pros: Great balance and melt-in-mouth texture; Cons: Packaging is basic. A fantastic everyday shortbread.

3. 3. Heatherfield Bakery Buttery Rounds

   Rating: 8.4/10

   Pros: Robust butter flavour; Cons: Slightly crumbly for dunking. Ideal with tea.

4. 4. Lochside Cottage Shortbread Fingers

   Rating: 8.1/10

   Pros: Consistent quality and good value; Cons: Not as melt-in-mouth as premium options.

5. 5. Argyll Artisan Shortbread

   Rating: 7.9/10

   Pros: Interesting rustic texture; Cons: A touch under-baked for our taste.

6. 6. Island Bakehouse Sea Salt Caramel Shortbread

   Rating: 7.6/10

   Pros: Modern flavour twist with caramel; Cons: Less traditional profile.

7. 7. Bonnie & Bairn Classic

   Rating: 7.4/10

   Pros: Good supermarket option; Cons: Slightly oily aftertaste.

8. 8. St. Kilda’s Shortbread Squares

   Rating: 7.0/10

   Pros: Eye-catching packaging; Cons: Texture inconsistent across batches.

9. 9. Inverness Homemade Range

   Rating: 6.6/10

   Pros: Charming rustic look; Cons: Too dense for many palates.

10. 10. Market Street Classic Biscuits

    Rating: 6.2/10

    Pros: Very affordable; Cons: Lacking in butteriness and crispness.

Highlights and buying advice

If you want to impress, choose Muirhead’s Highland Shortbread for its balance of texture and butter depth. For daily dunking with tea, Glenfinnan’s Original and Lochside Cottage are consistent performers and present excellent value. If you like experimental flavours, the Island Bakehouse Sea Salt Caramel brings a contemporary twist that pairs beautifully with espresso or dark tea.

Packaging and freshness

Tins preserve freshness best and also make memorable gifts. Resealable bags are practical, but once opened, shortbread is best eaten within a week to enjoy peak texture. For gifting beyond a week, consider tins or vacuum-sealed packs.

Final verdict

Shortbread is a delightful, simple indulgence. Our top pick delivers on butter, texture and presentation, but there are excellent choices at different price points. Consider what matters most to you — pure butter flavour, value, or novelty — and you’ll find a biscuit to love.

"Good shortbread sings with butter and finishes with a clean, crumbly hush." — Tasting team

Ordering: find all brands on Scots.Store or check local artisan bakers for limited batches. If you want personalised recommendations, tell us your tea preference and we’ll suggest the best match.